Learning is a complex process that involves a combination of personal responsibility and external factors. The GRE ‘Analyze an Issue’ essay prompt states that learning is primarily a matter of personal discipline and that students cannot be motivated by school or college alone. In this response, I will discuss the extent to which I agree or disagree with this statement and explain the reasoning behind my position.
Understanding the Prompt
The prompt is asking us to consider the role of personal discipline and external motivation in the process of learning. It presents the idea that personal discipline is the main factor in learning and argues that external factors such as school or college are not enough to motivate students. The prompt also asks us to consider the validity of this statement and how it may or may not hold true.
Pros:
- Personal discipline is a crucial element in the learning process. Without discipline, students may struggle to stay focused and motivated to learn.
- Individuals who possess strong personal discipline are more likely to take initiative, set goals, and actively seek out opportunities for learning.
- In today’s fast-paced society, where distractions are abundant, personal discipline is necessary to overcome these distractions and focus on learning.
- Personal discipline can also lead to better time management skills, allowing students to prioritize their studies and make the most out of their learning opportunities.
Cons:
- While personal discipline is important, it is not the only factor in learning. External motivation, such as a supportive learning environment or inspiring teachers, can also play a significant role in motivating students to learn.
- Not all students have the same level of personal discipline, and it would be unfair to hold them all to the same standard. Some students may struggle with self-discipline due to factors such as learning disabilities or personal challenges.
- External factors such as school or college can provide structure and guidance, making it easier for students to develop and maintain personal discipline.
- Personal discipline can also be shaped by external factors, such as a student’s upbringing or cultural background.
Example of a Perfect-Scoring GRE Essay (Score of 6)
Personal discipline is often touted as the key to success in learning. Many argue that students cannot rely solely on the motivation provided by school or college, but rather must cultivate their own sense of discipline in order to truly excel. While I agree that personal discipline is crucial in the learning process, I also believe that the role of schools and colleges should not be underestimated.
On one hand, I agree that personal discipline is essential in learning. Without self-motivation and determination, students may struggle to keep up with the rigorous demands of education. Learning requires a significant amount of time and effort, and without the discipline to prioritize and manage one’s time effectively, it can be easy to fall behind. In addition, personal discipline also involves qualities such as perseverance and resilience, which are crucial in overcoming challenges and setbacks in the learning process. Without these traits, students may give up easily when faced with difficult material or assignments.
However, I also believe that the statement neglects the important role that schools and colleges play in motivating students. While personal discipline is certainly necessary, it is not always sufficient on its own. Schools and colleges provide a structured environment and support system that can greatly aid in a student’s learning journey. Teachers and professors not only provide guidance and instruction, but also serve as role models and sources of inspiration for students. In addition, the organized curriculum and deadlines in a school setting can help to instill a sense of urgency and accountability in students, which can further enhance their personal discipline.
Furthermore, the statement fails to acknowledge that not all students have the same access to resources and opportunities. Students from disadvantaged backgrounds may not have the same level of support and encouragement from their schools or families, making personal discipline even more challenging for them. In this case, schools and colleges must step in to provide additional support and motivation, as well as address any barriers that may hinder a student’s ability to cultivate personal discipline.
In conclusion, while personal discipline is undoubtedly important in learning, it is not the sole factor that determines a student’s success. Schools and colleges play a crucial role in providing the necessary structure and support for students to thrive academically. It is only through a combination of personal discipline and external motivation that students can truly excel in their learning journey. Therefore, I believe that both personal discipline and the support of schools and colleges are vital in achieving academic success.